ChatGPT’s analysis of the JSE Top 40

The JSE Top 40 is a diverse, liquid index with long-term growth potential but can be volatile and present a currency risk.

This is artificial intelligence chatbot ChatGPT’s analysis of the JSE Top 40 when asked by Daily Investor to provide reasons to invest in the index, and reasons not to.

ChatGPT is a chatbot launched by OpenAI in November 2022, which is built on top of OpenAI’s GPT-3 family of large language models.

As an AI language model, ChatGPT is not licensed or qualified to provide financial advice.

Thus, when asked to give information on a particular stock or whether something is a good investment, the response ChatGPT gives is only for informational purposes.

The JSE Top 40 is a market capitalisation-weighted index of the largest 40 companies listed on the JSE.

---

ChatGPT’s five reasons why the JSE Top 40 could be a good investment:

• Diversification

“Investing in the JSE Top 40 offers exposure to a diversified range of industries and sectors, which can help reduce the risk of investing in a single company or industry.”

Some of the sectors represented in the JSE Top 40 are mining, financial services, telecommunications and consumer goods.

Diversification is important in a portfolio because it reduces risk by decreasing exposure to any single asset or market event that could negatively impact a portfolio.

In addition to reducing risk, diversification can also help investors capture different growth opportunities across multiple industries and sectors.

• Long-term growth potential

“Over the long term, equity investments in a diverse range of companies with strong fundamentals have the potential to generate attractive returns for investors.”

The companies that form part of the JSE Top 40 have a proven track record of delivering strong earnings growth and consistent dividend payments to shareholders. 

These factors can help to drive long-term returns, according to ChatGPT.

• Exposure to well-established companies 

“The JSE Top 40 is made up of some of the most well-established and reputable companies in South Africa, which can help investors feel more confident about their investments.”

Some companies that form part of the JSE Top 40 are Absa, Anglo American, BHP, British American Tobacco, Capitec, Discovery, Glencore, MultiChoice and Standard Bank.

Many of the companies included in the JSE Top 40 have existed for years and are well-established roleplayers in their respective industries.

• Liquidity

“The JSE Top 40 is a highly liquid market, meaning that there are typically many buyers and sellers in the market, making it easier to buy and sell shares.”

The JSE Top 40 is considered “liquid” because it is one of the most actively-traded indices on the JSE. This is largely because of the high trading volume of the 40 companies. 

The reason liquidity can be attractive for investors is that they can more easily buy and sell shares at a fair market price.

• Track record

“Historically, the JSE Top 40 has been a strong performer, with many of the constituent companies consistently delivering solid earnings and dividend growth over time.”

Because many of the companies that form part of the JSE Top 40 have existed for years and are well-established, they have a large performance history and track record that can guide an investor’s decisions.

---

ChatGPT’s five reasons why the JSE Top 40 could not be a good investment

• Concentrated exposure

“Despite being a diversified index, the JSE Top 40 still represents a relatively small subset of the overall market, which could limit an investor’s exposure to certain sectors or industries that are not well-represented.”

According to the JSE’s website, its financial aggregation has more than 800 listed securities and approximately 400 listed companies, together with 60 equity market member firms.

The 40 companies that form part of the index, therefore, make up only a small percentage of the market.

• Volatility

“As with any equity investment, the JSE Top 40 can be volatile, and there is no guarantee that past performance will be repeated in the future.”

Past performance is not an indicator of a company’s future performance and it is therefore not guaranteed that a reputable, well-established company will consistently deliver good returns.

Volatility can also increase the risk of short-term losses, especially if investors need to sell their investments during a market downturn.

However, it should be noted that volatility is not necessarily a negative attribute. Some investors may actively seek out volatility as an opportunity to buy stocks at lower prices or sell stocks at higher prices.

• Currency risk

“As many of the constituent companies in the JSE Top 40 are exposed to international markets, there is a risk that currency fluctuations could negatively impact returns for investors.”

JSE Top 40 companies like Anglo American, British American Tobacco, Richemont and Prosus are multinational or global companies exposed to international markets.

However, currency risk can also present opportunities for investors. For example, if the rand weakens against other currencies, the returns of JSE Top 40 companies that earn revenue in foreign currencies could benefit from the currency translation effect.

Particularly in South Africa, where the rand is weak and often volatile, currency risk is an important factor for South African investors to consider.

• Country risk

“Investing in South Africa comes with its own unique set of risks, including political instability, regulatory uncertainty, and socioeconomic factors.”

South Africa’s political instability, economic volatility, currency risk, infrastructure challenges, and social inequality can make it a risky country to invest in.

• Limited growth potential

“While the JSE Top 40 has historically performed well, there may be limited upside potential for investors who are looking for higher-growth opportunities, especially compared to other emerging markets.”

For investors who prioritise stability and consistent income over growth, this is not necessarily a negative attribute.

However, for those seeking higher returns, mature industries or companies with limited opportunities for expansion offer lower potential for capital appreciation or long-term returns compared to other investments with higher growth potential.