South Africa could pay twice for the same product from a company it spent R3 billion to save
The proposed takeover of ArcelorMittal South Africa (AMSA) by the Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) could see South Africa paying twice for its steel.
Recent reports indicate that the takeover could involve R3 billion in cash and the assumption of R7 billion in AMSA debt.
The company’s stock exchange disclosures revealed that talks are at an advanced stage, with conditions and approvals still outstanding.
ArcelorMittal is South Africa’s biggest steel producer and one of the country’s largest industrial employers.
The company has struggled in recent years against deteriorating infrastructure, operational failures and incidents, and an influx of Chinese subsidised steel imports since 2015.
AMSA posted a headline loss of R1.49 billion for the first six months of 2026, with its crude steel production down by 35%.
Earlier this year, the company filed an application with the International Trade Administration Commission (ITAC) for an investigation into the impact of imported steel on local production.
AMSA has argued that cheap steel imports have diminished its sales and market share in recent years, leading to its substantial losses.
The IDC’s relationship with AMSA stretches back three decades to when it formed a 50/50 joint venture with the company’s predecessor, Iscor, to build the Saldanha Steel Mill in 1996.
Following AMSA’s warning that it would wind down its long-steel operations in November 2023, the IDC began negotiations to support the struggling company.
In June 2024, the IDC extended a R1 billion working capital loan facility to keep AMSA liquid, followed by another facility of R1.68 billion in March 2025.
This deferred the closure of its Newcastle, Vereeniging, and eMalahleni plants and prevented roughly 3,500 workers from being suspended.
The IDC said the facility was repayable by agreement between the parties and intended to support AMSA until a more viable, long-term solution could be reached.
IDC offers to buy AMSA

After three years of negotiations, the IDC reached a preliminary agreement to buy AMSA for roughly R10 billion in October 2026.
This would bring AMSA back under state control nearly four decades after its predecessor, Iscor, privatised and listed on the JSE in 1989.
The proposed acquisition has drawn criticism from industry bodies and parties such as the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA).
OUTA has argued that putting AMSA under government control would put more of the IDC’s capital at risk, giving the government an incentive to protect its investment if losses continue.
“This is how South Africa could end up paying twice,” OUTA said. “The first bill sits on the Industrial Development Corporation’s balance sheet.”
“The second comes through the price of steel. The government has already imposed import duties and other trade protections on selected steel products.”
The organisation warned that if these duties were raised even higher to keep AMSA in business, steel users could end up paying part of the rescue cost.
Domestic fabricators would need to pay more to buy steel and move products, reducing their competitiveness against suppliers from China, India, and the United Arab Emirates.
OUTA said steel customers would have no obligation to pay a premium to support South Africa’s industrial policy, and could shop contracts elsewhere.
The organisation said that while protecting jobs at AMSA was important, so too was protecting jobs in companies that purchase its steel products.
It said the IDC should first show which steel grades South Africa needs to produce, the cost to modernise AMSA’s facilities, and where the company would procure the skills it needs.
“The IDC and AMSA’s leadership should explain how the business expects to earn a return under realistic assumptions about electricity, freight, demand, and import competition,” OUTA said.
“If buying AMSA only works by making everyone else pay more for steel, the Industrial Development Corporation should walk away.”
Login or register for unlimited free access.