Takealot and Makro’s fight against Shein

Shein is the most downloaded shopping app on South Africa’s Google Play store. And it isn’t even trying that hard.

The Singapore-based fast-fashion brand launched in the country at the foot of the continent during the Covid-19 pandemic and is expanding via word-of-mouth and by offering first-time buyer discounts.

It has already caused such a stir that local retailers are spooked, and regulators are investigating if it has exploited import tax loopholes when sending parcels to shoppers.

Taahira Khumalo, a 24-year-old receptionist in Johannesburg, says she now buys all her clothes online. Shein is a brand she keeps returning to, lured by its competitive prices, on-trend fashion and speed of delivery.

“Shein offers really good discounts, and I don’t wait long for my parcels to arrive,” she said. “Since the pandemic, technology has improved, and now I really don’t need to leave the comfort of my home to shop.”

Shein, founded in China, is gaining a foothold in a nascent e-commerce market in the most industrialised country in Africa and is squaring up to US giants Walmart and, who want to do the same.

Online acceleration

Walmart has tried to win local hearts the traditional way, buying into domestic retail group Massmart Holdings more than a decade ago in an expensive move that so far has failed to live up to expectations.

Massmart owns prominent brands in South Africa, including Makro, Game, and Builders Warehouse, which all have their own online shops.

Amazon, which has been providing web services in the country of about 60 million people since 2004, is expected to launch its e-commerce delivery business in South Africa in the coming months.

With rapidly growing populations but little formal retail and even less Internet shopping, many retailers know they will eventually have to figure out how to make Africa work for them — and South Africa is the most obvious place to start.

“Amazon and Shein are going to accelerate online shopping in South Africa beyond recognition,” said Anthony Thunström, chief executive officer of The Foschini Group, a local retailer that owns Jet, a discount clothing chain.

“South Africa has been very slow adopting digital or online shopping, so I think the competition’s good.”

South Africa has a growing middle class. Nearly three-quarters of the country has Internet access, and more people live in concentrated urban areas than in most other nations in the region.

E-commerce makes up about 4% of retail in the country, meaning there are potential riches to be won.

Early mover advantage hasn’t really helped Walmart, though. When the US retailer first bought into Massmart, which sells clothes, fridges and washing machines alongside tinned foods, it had ambitions to expand with stores across Africa. But subpar infrastructure and difficulties finding good real estate have dimmed that dream.

Instead, in the last three years, it has focused on building its South African online sales and sent Sylvester John, one of its e-commerce experts, to Johannesburg to make Massmart South Africa’s top general merchandise website with same-day fulfilment.

Massmart is already revamping its websites, and the re-designs are focused on ensuring they’re formatted for mobile devices first, instead of desktop.

That’s because of the strong preference of South African consumers to browse and shop online on their mobile devices, according to John.

Last year the value of goods sold online by Massmart rose more than 90% to R2.3 billion, helping justify Walmart’s decision to buy out the unit in preparation to go head-to-head with arch-rival Amazon.

Though it has yet to set a firm date for its retail launch in the country, Amazon has been advertising for local recruits in recent months.

The Seattle-based company won permission in June to continue building a local headquarters near Cape Town after a halt due to a dispute with an indigenous group over the land’s traditional use.

Online Inroads

Global retailers’ inroads into South Africa come even as the country’s antitrust regulator examines how e-commerce prices are formulated and as the country battles with erratic electricity supply which is severely hampering economic growth.

“Africa has shown its ability to leapfrog when it comes to technology — we’ve seen this in online banking and mobile money, and I think we are seeing it in purchases made with apps,” said Alec Abraham, an analyst at Sasfin Securities in Johannesburg.

“While the South African economy is currently floundering, getting big players like this putting a foot in the door demonstrates the potential that sits within this market.”

Local retailers are already trying to get ahead of the latest global scramble for South Africa, expanding both what they offer online and how quickly they can deliver orders.

Thunström’s TFG recently launched its fashion and lifestyle shopping platform, Bash, in just nine months.

“We realized that the future battle was going to be against the Sheins and Amazons of the world,” he said. “Normally this takes two years, but we knew we had to push to do it quicker than that and do it well.”

There are some growing concerns, however, about whether all retailers will operate on a level playing field. South Africa’s local industry association as well as the textile union have already complained to the government that they suspect Shein is possibly exploiting customs tax loopholes.

Growing Competition

“We don’t mind competition as long as it’s by the rules,” said Pieter Erasmus, CEO of Pepkor Holdings, Africa’s largest clothing retailer.

Shein complies with all local laws and regulations and remains open to engage and cooperate with the South African government, a spokesperson said, adding that the retailer finds the local market interesting.

Paying far more than expected for her Shein order to pass through South African customs was Agnes Rammutla’s recent experience. The 25-year-old dentist has been buying from Shein for about a year.

There was no glitch with her other six orders, but this time local authorities made her stump up more in custom duties before releasing the parcel.

“Like me, all my friends buy online, but I guess there can be a risk,” Rammutla said.


Top JSE indices