South Africa’s Treasury is finalizing a plan to take over a portion of Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd.’s 396 billion rand ($24 billion) debt as part of a process to place the struggling electricity company on a sustainable footing, a top official said. The company’s bonds surged.
The “broad brush strokes” of the debt transfer will be announced in the mid-term budget scheduled for October, Duncan Pieterse, head of assets and liability management at the National Treasury, said in an interview Wednesday. The authorities will seek cabinet and parliament’s approval for the plan after determining the amount, along with the conditions the utility will need to meet before and following such a transaction.
The Treasury has done financial modeling around the debt transfer and appointed lawyers to advise it on regulatory and legal hurdles, including loan covenants, Pieterse said. It’s also working with Eskom to determine what needs to be done to ensure the state-owned company is sustainable after the debt transfer has taken place.
“There is no point in dealing with the debt, only for the entity to return to the fiscus for further support,” Pieterse said. “Then you are basically executing a debt transfer without making sure that you will have a sustainable entity in the end,” he said, adding that “Eskom has been very constructive in our engagements with them.”
Setting a plan for Eskom’s debt would mark a key step toward turning around the engine that drives Africa’s most industrialized nation, after years of government bailouts and rolling power outages that have weighed on the economy. The utility has been unbundling into generation, distribution and transmission units in a strategy to update the nearly century-old monopoly, but the government has been stymied by the debt pile that’s required cash injections just to service.
A debt transfer “means reduced risk of default and I believe would be the right step to solve Eskom’s debt problems,” said Patrik Kauffmann, a Zurich-based money manager at Aquila Asset Management AG, which holds Eskom bonds.
Eskom’s bonds surged the most since May 2020, with yields on unsecured 2028 dollar securities dropping 152 basis points to 11.17% by 5 p.m. in Johannesburg. Yields on benchmark 10-year government rand bonds fell 23 basis points to 10.87%, and the rand reversed a decline of as much as 0.8% to trade 0.6% stronger against the dollar at 16.5864.
Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana said in his February budget statement that the Treasury would work on a plan to find a “fair and equitable” debt solution for Eskom by the end of the current financial year. The debt-transfer proposal flows from that announcement, Pieterse said.
“Once the technical work is complete, then this work has to be subjected to budget processes and be incorporated and tested within the fiscal framework, which is ultimately approved by the minister of finance, cabinet and parliament,” Pieterse said. “As announced by the president, we intend to outline the principles of the proposal at the time of the medium-term budget policy statement in October and the execution modalities thereafter.”
Yields on South African local-currency government bonds are among the highest in emerging markets, an ascent that accelerated from 2017, when Eskom started to face mounting fiscal and governance issues. Goldman Sachs Group identified the utility as the biggest single threat to the nation’s economy.
In 2019, Eskom received a multibillion dollar bailout, which resulted in the government increasing the amount of debt it sold at weekly auctions, driving up yields. The following year the Public Investment Corp., a manager of government workers’ pensions and unemployment funds, emerged as the potential counter-party of an Eskom debt-for-equity swap. Other solutions have since emerged and faded.
“They are finally progressing through to a solution, which will help Eskom to remove the impediment that’s stopped it from adequately allocating its capital,” said Willem Visser, a London-based credit analyst at T Rowe Price, which holds Eskom bonds. “If this relief does come, then the senior management of Eskom should get the support it needs to tackle the lackluster electricity availability and general performance.”
Among the other proposals to help reduce Eskom’s debt is one resurrected by Godongwana to sell some of its coal-fired power plants. That idea is still under consideration, Pieterse said.
“In terms of the selling of power plants, it is something that we have asked Eskom to look into and it is obviously tricky,” he said. “That is one of the issues under discussion, but it isn’t the main issue. The main issue is how do you create the space for Eskom to maintain the plants they currently have and to invest in the transmission and distribution parts of their business.”
Taking a large portion of Eskom’s debt onto the state’s balance sheet may help lower South Africa’s borrowing costs by removing the uncertainty that’s built into sovereign yields, Pieterse said.
“The question is what happens to our risk premium going forward,” he said. “The feedback we have received has been along the lines of, provided you can get the right conditions in place, provided it is a credible transaction, this can actually be net positive for the sovereign.”
It is unlikely that the transfer would undermine the government’s efforts to consolidate debt and improve the country’s credit ratings, said Peter Worthington, a senior economist at Absa Group Ltd. in Johannesburg, who estimates it would add about 200 billion rand to the state’s balance sheet, based on Eskom’s own projections.
“Anybody sensible understood that it was on the government’s balance sheet anyway” and the rating companies have treated it as such, Worthington said. “So this is just a reshuffling between two parts of the sovereign in a way that will hopefully free up the one part, i.e. Eskom, to move forward on a more solid independent basis.”