How is your plan B coming along?
By Magnus Heystek*
For more than a decade and even longer, Dr Frans Cronje, formerly CEO of the Institute of Race Relations (IRR) and now Frans Cronje Private Clients, has been a sober, fact-based commentator on South African political and economic issues.
As a regular contributor and also multi-time speaker at BizNews conferences, Cronje’s analysis is sought after and appreciated for what they are: an honest and research-based views, rather than politically tainted views that suits to promote certain secular interests.
It’s interesting therefore, that Cronje, via his newish website The Common Sense has spent some considerable time and coverage on what he calls the “enclavement movement” in South Africa, where well-to-do people of all races are moving to protect themselves from the collapsing services which should have been the function of the state and other state owned enterprises (SOE’s).
In a recent article on his website, he goes even further and strongly recommends certain steps families must take to protect themselves and their children. What is surprising is not the plan itself, but the fact that as a leading commentator he is prepared to publicly call for the construct of a Plan B.
Heaven forbids an economist or asset manager from one of our large investment companies should propagate such a move. This would probably be a short -cut to dismissal and a career-ending move.
Cronje is simply stating what savvy investors and families have been doing for many years.
I have been a strong advocate of a Plan B, which ranges from simply moving some money offshore, into creating an alternative business and residency alternative to South Africa, without having to actually emigrate. The Just in case scenario.
Obviously, not every family has the ways and means of doing so, but it nevertheless remains a strong consideration for those who are looking past the current period of relative stability to safeguard their lives, assets, children, and businesses.
What should a Plan B look for South African families?
For a South African family, I would define a Plan B as resilience, not emigration. The objective is to make sure that a family’s wealth, income, mobility, and succession do not depend entirely on South Africa continuing to function in exactly the way you hope it will.
A sensible Plan B has several layers:
1. Geographic diversification of wealth. A meaningful portion of long-term wealth should be invested offshore in hard currencies and global assets. The purpose isn’t to make a call against South Africa; it’s to reduce concentration in one country, currency, banking system, and economy. The appropriate percentage depends heavily on the family’s spending needs, tax position, age, and liabilities.
2. Maintain sufficient South African liquidity. Keep enough accessible rand liquidity for normal expenditure and emergencies rather than moving everything offshore. Bank concentration is worth considering too: South Africa’s CODI deposit-insurance scheme currently protects qualifying deposits only up to R100,000 per depositor per bank.
3. Create genuine international optionality. This might mean maintaining foreign bank and investment accounts, keeping passports current, investigating residence rights or second residency where appropriate, and having enough offshore liquidity to fund an extended period abroad. This does not necessarily mean acquiring a second passport or leaving South Africa.
4. Diversify the family’s income. For business owners especially, a powerful Plan B is earning part of the family’s income in dollars, euros, or pounds – through foreign clients, investments, businesses, or other legitimate international sources. This reduces dependence on both the rand and domestic economic growth.
5. Get the ownership structure right. Offshore assets should not simply accumulate without considering tax, estate duty, foreign succession laws, and structures. Depending on the circumstances, trusts, companies, life policies, or direct ownership can produce very different outcomes. The structure should follow the family’s objectives rather than the other way around. I strongly recommend that investors with offshore assets – anything in excess of R10m consider setting up a foreign trust in jurisdictions such as Mauritius, Malta, or Guernsey.
6. Have an estate and succession Plan B. Every adult should have an up-to-date will, and business owners need shareholder agreements dealing with death, disability, and the sale of shares. South Africa’s Master specifically recommends a properly prepared will and notes that it determines beneficiaries and allows you to nominate an executor. If trusts are used, they need to be properly administered; trustees may not act without written authority from the Master.
7. Build family capability outside South Africa. Children’s education, international qualifications, foreign work experience, and professional networks can be as important as offshore investments. A family with R50 million offshore but no practical ability to operate internationally doesn’t necessarily have a complete Plan B. It is notable amongst clients of Brenthurst that their children undergo tertiary education that enables global careers in accounting, engineering, medicine, and actuarial sciences, for instance. SA graduates in these disciplines are in great demand all over the English-speaking world.
8. Keep a South African Plan A. This is important. A Plan B shouldn’t require you to sell your home, business, or South African investments simply because risks exist. South Africa can still offer attractive businesses, property, and investments. The aim is to avoid being forced into a decision by a future crisis.
9. Many South Africans have over the past ten years and more sold their under-performing and non-performing properties outside of the Western Cape and either moved down to the Cape or kept the Western Cape property as a future residence, if practical considerations do not warrant a move down South at the current time. This has been a smart move. Residential property prices in an upmarket suburb such as Dainfern, Johannesburg, where I live, has shown annual growth of a mere 2.2% per annum over 10 years. Meanwhile, property prices in Val de Vie in the Western Cape outside of Paarl, where I invested ten years ago, has shown annual growth of about 15% per annum over the same period.
What this might look like for a wealthy SA family
Take a hypothetical family with R100 million of investable assets. Rather than treating Plan B as “leave South Africa”, I might think about it conceptually as: R35m to R50m in South African assets and liquidity, R40m to R55m in diversified global investments held offshore, and perhaps R5m to R10m of highly liquid foreign-currency reserves and/or assets associated with international mobility.
Those numbers aren’t an investment recommendation – they illustrate the principle that Plan B money needs to be genuinely accessible outside South Africa, rather than merely owning foreign shares through a South African structure.
There is also an important distinction between offshore investing and emigration planning. A family can build substantial international financial resilience while remaining South African residents. Conversely, somebody can emigrate while still having most of their economic risk tied to South Africa.
One useful local building block shouldn’t be overlooked either: from 1 March 2026, the annual contribution limit for South African tax-free investments increased from R36 000 to R46 000; qualifying returns are free of income tax, dividends tax and capital gains tax.
I would summarize the philosophy as:
Plan A: Live, work, invest and build wealth in South Africa.
Plan B: Ensure that if South Africa experiences a severe political, currency, fiscal or infrastructure shock, your family’s capital, income, mobility, and succession arrangements continue functioning normally.
And for wealthy South African families there is arguably a third component:
Plan C: Make sure the next generation can inherit and manage the family’s international wealth efficiently, regardless of where they ultimately live.
Click here to contact Brenthurst Wealth.
* Magnus Heystek is a co-founder and investment strategist at Brenthurst Wealth, SA’s largest independent advisory business.